Open Umay
United States
Pastrami Reuben sandwich
A great New York deli classic: butter-toasted rye bread, hot pastrami, melted cheese, tangy sauerkraut, and creamy Russian dressing. Rich, crispy, juicy, and perfectly balanced.
4 servings20 min prep15 min cook
4 servings
Ingredients
sliced rye bread8 slicesbase
sliced beef pastrami500 g (1.1 lb)base
sliced Emmental cheese8 slicespairing
plain cooked sauerkraut240 g (8.5 oz)pairing
unsalted butter40 g (2 7/8 tbsp)pantry
homemade Russian dressing160 ml (2/3 cup)prepared_component
mayonnaise100 g (3.5 oz)pantry
ketchup40 g (1.4 oz)pantry
jarred grated horseradish1 tbsppantry
Worcestershire sauce1 tsppantry
sweet-and-sour pickles30 g (1.1 oz)pantry
Steps
- Prepare the Russian dressing if making it homemade: mix the dressing ingredients until you achieve a creamy, pinkish-orange texture with small flecks of pickle, then set aside in the refrigerator.
- Carefully drain the sauerkraut and squeeze it lightly; it should remain juicy to the taste but no longer release liquid when pressed.
- Gently warm the pastrami in a covered skillet or by steaming until it is pliable, hot, and fragrant, without letting it brown or dry out.
- Butter one side of each slice of rye bread, then place the buttered sides facing outward to prepare for assembly.
- Spread the Russian dressing on the inside of the bread, add the cheese, the hot pastrami, and the well-drained sauerkraut, then close the sandwich, pressing down just enough to keep it compact.
- Heat a large skillet over medium-low heat and place the sandwiches inside; cook until the bottom is deeply golden, crispy, and smells of brown butter.
- Flip carefully, then continue cooking until the other side is golden and the cheese begins to melt around the edges.
- Let rest briefly on a cutting board to stabilize the filling, then cut diagonally and serve immediately, while the bread still crackles under the knife.
Why it works
Chef notes
More recipes like this





