Butter-Grilled Lobster

A great seafood classic: split lobster, grilled quickly, then drizzled with frothy butter flavored with parsley, garlic, and lemon. The meat stays juicy and slightly smoky, with a simple sauce that respects all its sweet, briny flavor.

4 servings20 min prep14 min cook
4 servings

Ingredients

live lobster, or pre-cooked, or frozen raw lobster, thawed4base
unsalted butter180 g (3/4 cup)pantry
garlic2 clovespantry
flat-leaf parsley0.5 bunchesgarnish
lemon2pairing
olive oil2 tbsppantry
fine saltto tastepantry
ground black pepperto tastepantry

Steps

  1. Prepare the flavored butter: gently melt the butter with the finely minced garlic, then let it froth until it smells nutty without browning heavily.
  2. Off the heat, add the chopped parsley, a squeeze of lemon juice, salt, and pepper; keep this butter warm so it stays fluid and glossy.
  3. Put the lobsters to sleep in the cold if using them live, then split them lengthwise with a heavy knife; remove the sand sac and keep the coral if present.
  4. Pat the meat dry, brush lightly with olive oil, salt, and pepper; the surface should be just glistening, not drowning in fat.
  5. Heat the broiler, a griddle, or a home barbecue until very hot; the heat is ready when the shell sizzles immediately upon contact.
  6. Place the lobster halves meat-side toward the heat and sear them until the meat begins to turn opaque and the edges firm up.
  7. Turn shell-side down, baste generously with the flavored butter, and continue cooking, basting often, until the meat is pearlescent, springy, and easily detaches from the shell.
  8. Add a final squeeze of lemon, a little fresh parsley, and serve immediately with the remaining warm butter on the side.
Open in Umay